KRFL - a football simulation league
Forums
KRFL :: Forums :: KRFL Forums :: 2020 League Business
Limit Trading of Rookie and Free Agent Draft Picks to the Next Draft << Previous thread | Next thread >>
Go to page       >>  
Moderators: noodles, MarkB
Author Post
MarkB
Sun Mar 22 2020, 06:04p.m.
Mark Blume

Registered Member #81
Joined: Mon Oct 14 2013, 08:54a.m.

Posts: 1282
Current Rules:
7.1 In season trading

7.3a Trading during the Rookie Draft:
Trades may involve rookie draft picks (including next year's)

7.3b Trading during the Free Agent Draft
Trades may involve drafted rookies, next year's rookie picks, players under contract, and picks in the current Free Agent Draft.

Proposed Rules:
7.1 In Season Trading
Only picks in the next season's Rookie of Free Agent drafts can be traded. For example, during the 2020 KRFL season, only 2021 Rookie Draft picks or 2021 Free Agent Draft picks can be traded. Picks in either 2022 draft are after cannot be traded.

7.3a In Draft Trading - Rookie Draft
Trades may involve rookie draft picks in the next unstarted rookie draft only. For example, until the 2020 Rookie Draft begins, only 2020 Rookie Draft picks can be traded. Once the 2020 Rookie Draft begins, then 2021 Rookie Draft picks can be traded. But 2022 Rookie Draft Picks cannot be traded until the 2021 Rookie Draft begins.

7.3b In Draft Trading - Free Agent Draft
Trades may involve drafted rookies, rookie draft picks in the next rookie draft only, players under contract, and picks in the current Free Agent Draft. Insofar as the Rookie Draft picks, During the 2020 Free Draft, only 2021 Rookie Draft picks can be traded. Once the 2021 Rookie Draft begins, then 2022 Rookie Draft picks can be traded.


Justification: Prevent trades like http://www.aaroncraneinstitute.com/football/e107_plugins/forum/forum_post.php?rp.12741.last which I don't think are in the best interest of the league and it may prevent "Tanking" by teams.
Back to top
KRFL-BayCity
Sun Mar 22 2020, 07:39p.m.
Registered Member #12
Joined: Mon Sep 01 2008, 07:40p.m.

Posts: 720
Bay City would support....
Back to top
noodles
Sun Mar 22 2020, 07:46p.m.
Webmaster

Registered Member #1
Joined: Mon Feb 18 2008, 02:12a.m.

Posts: 1185
Rolling Green supports.
Back to top
mark
Mon Mar 23 2020, 09:10a.m.
Registered Member #45
Joined: Wed May 05 2010, 11:29p.m.

Posts: 667
Yes. I support
Back to top
jonwolgamuth
Mon Mar 23 2020, 09:07p.m.
Registered Member #92
Joined: Sun Jan 28 2018, 01:51p.m.

Posts: 29
Agree with this change
Back to top
Steelers
Tue Mar 24 2020, 07:35a.m.
Registered Member #100
Joined: Sat Jan 25 2020, 07:43p.m.

Posts: 60
I would oppose this amendment because we already have a trading committee which has the power to reject one sided trades. I also believe a free market is the best way to allow a team to prosper and rebuild and this amendment appears to place further restrictions on how to run your team.
Back to top
sjenk
Wed Mar 25 2020, 09:39p.m.
Registered Member #73
Joined: Sat Mar 30 2013, 01:40a.m.

Posts: 178
I support.
Back to top
MarkB
Tue Mar 31 2020, 10:29p.m.
Mark Blume

Registered Member #81
Joined: Mon Oct 14 2013, 08:54a.m.

Posts: 1282
Steelers wrote ...

I would oppose this amendment because we already have a trading committee which has the power to reject one sided trades. I also believe a free market is the best way to allow a team to prosper and rebuild and this amendment appears to place further restrictions on how to run your team.


-------------
While the trading committee is active and has been used, it has rarely rejected trades. I don't see that as a good fall back to a proposal that has the support of a number of members.
Back to top
Salem
Tue Mar 31 2020, 10:53p.m.
Registered Member #25
Joined: Sun Sep 07 2008, 10:07p.m.

Posts: 613
I am thinking of making Jimmy G available for trade this offseason. When the raitings come out in a couple of days - or the disk comes out at the end of April, are you saying I can't trade Jimmy G for a 2021 draft pick? I can only trade him for a draft pick for our draft that starts in June? If so, I vote no. Really limits - potentially - who I can trade with.
Back to top
MarkB
Tue Mar 31 2020, 11:00p.m.
Mark Blume

Registered Member #81
Joined: Mon Oct 14 2013, 08:54a.m.

Posts: 1282
Salem wrote ...

I am thinking of making Jimmy G available for trade this offseason. When the raitings come out in a couple of days - or the disk comes out at the end of April, are you saying I can't trade Jimmy G for a 2021 draft pick? I can only trade him for a draft pick for our draft that starts in June? If so, I vote no. Really limits - potentially - who I can trade with.


------------------
If this proposal were to pass, that is correct.
Back to top
Go to page       >>   

Jump:     Back to top

Syndicate this thread: rss 0.92 Syndicate this thread: rss 2.0 Syndicate this thread: RDF
Powered by e107 Forum System