KRFL - a football simulation league
Forums
KRFL :: Forums :: KRFL Forums :: 2020 League Business
Amendment Proposal: Lottery Tournament for Draft Order << Previous thread | Next thread >>
Go to page       >>  
Moderators: noodles, MarkB
Author Post
Steelers
Sat Mar 21 2020, 01:07p.m.
Registered Member #100
Joined: Sat Jan 25 2020, 07:43p.m.

Posts: 60
Individual Proposal for Draft Lottery Tournament for Non-Playoff Teams

( This proposal should only be used in the event the original comprehensive package is not approved )

5.1 Determination of Draft Order for KRFL teams is based on the record and playoff finish by each team in the previous season. The selection order is based on each team’s won-loss record in the previous regular season and whether the team reached the playoffs.

Teams that did not reach the playoffs will participate in a lottery tournament to determine the draft order for the first 12 picks in the next draft. The tournament will follow the same playoff rules contained in Rule 11 with the following exceptions:

1. Lottery Playoff for 12 non playoff teams will follow similar process as Regular Playoff:

- Round 1: 4 teams with best records get first round byes. Remaining 8 teams are seeded 1-8 based on winning percentage and play first round games.. ( 1-8, 2-7,3-6, 4-5)
-Round 2: 8 remaining teams seeded 1-8 based on winning percentages and play
-Round 3: 4 remaining teams seeded 1-4 based on winning percentages and play
-Round 4: 2 remaining teams play each other

Draft Order for First 12 positions:

1. Lottery Playoff Champ
2. Round 4 Loser
3-4: Round 3 Losers
5-8: Round 2 Losers
9-12:Round 1 Losers

At the end of the lottery tournament, the draft order will be awarded as follows:

1. Lottery Playoff Champion
2. Round 4 Loser
3-4. 2 Round 3 Losers ranked based on tie breaker record
5-8 . 4 Round 2 Losers ranked based on tie breaker record
9-12. Round 1 Losers ranked based on tie breaker record

“ Tie breaker records” are based on the following:

The team with the ……..

Back to top
KRFL-BayCity
Sat Mar 21 2020, 04:31p.m.
Registered Member #12
Joined: Mon Sep 01 2008, 07:40p.m.

Posts: 720
I would not support this.... it is hard enough for many to finish a 16 game season, without asking them to play another possible 4 games....
Back to top
Steelers
Sat Mar 21 2020, 04:44p.m.
Registered Member #100
Joined: Sat Jan 25 2020, 07:43p.m.

Posts: 60
We have playoff games: same number of games in same time period.
What is the difference ??
Back to top
Salem
Sat Mar 21 2020, 07:48p.m.
Registered Member #25
Joined: Sun Sep 07 2008, 10:07p.m.

Posts: 613
I support putting this on the ballot.
Back to top
KRFL-BayCity
Sun Mar 22 2020, 11:48a.m.
Registered Member #12
Joined: Mon Sep 01 2008, 07:40p.m.

Posts: 720
the difference is you are forcing 12 crappier teams to extend their season....
Back to top
Steelers
Sun Mar 22 2020, 12:56p.m.
Registered Member #100
Joined: Sat Jan 25 2020, 07:43p.m.

Posts: 60
not sure why it would be such a burden ?
Back to top
mark
Mon Mar 23 2020, 09:13a.m.
Registered Member #45
Joined: Wed May 05 2010, 11:29p.m.

Posts: 667
I don’t support. I will SIM my games if passed.
Back to top
jonwolgamuth
Mon Mar 23 2020, 09:05p.m.
Registered Member #92
Joined: Sun Jan 28 2018, 01:51p.m.

Posts: 29
Steelers wrote ...

We have playoff games: same number of games in same time period.
What is the difference ??


I like the fresh approach. I like the idea of this sort of a change and it should be voted on in some form. I'm certainly willing to stay involved at the end of a bad season if it means I can make my team better.
Back to top
mark
Tue Mar 24 2020, 08:02a.m.
Registered Member #45
Joined: Wed May 05 2010, 11:29p.m.

Posts: 667
Salem wrote ...

I support putting this on the ballot.

I would rather implement one of the options we discussed earlier.
Back to top
rsarce
Tue Mar 24 2020, 09:22p.m.
Registered Member #15
Joined: Tue Sep 02 2008, 01:00p.m.

Posts: 241
I do not support this, and if it should pass I will resign from the league immediately.....any process that 'rewards' the best non playoff team with the best pick in the draft is seriously flawed and would destroy competitive balance. I also resent the implication that a team having a bad season is 'tanking'....
Back to top
Go to page       >>   

Jump:     Back to top

Syndicate this thread: rss 0.92 Syndicate this thread: rss 2.0 Syndicate this thread: RDF
Powered by e107 Forum System