KRFL - a football simulation league
KRFL :: Forums :: KRFL Forums :: General League Discussions
2017 DRAFT - GRADE AFTER TWO SEASONS << Previous thread | Next thread >>
Moderators: noodles, MarkB
Author Post
Tue Mar 12 2019, 07:01a.m.
Registered Member #68
Joined: Wed Sep 14 2011, 01:54p.m.

Posts: 129
Hi guys

Again, just for fine

ALABAMA C Sure coach Haucke could do better. For now best pick is ILB Walker

Taco Charlton DE Only four sacks in two years. No great for first round pick
Aaron Jones RB 5.5 avg is fantastic for RB. Only problem is injury (lost 8 games in two years)
ArDarius Stewart WR Already out from NFL
Anthony Walker ILB After no good rookie season it has become starter MLB for Indianapolis
Joe Williams RB Probably never play in NFL

ATLANTA A Only pick Kittle can justify this grade. If add Cunningham and Mack this is very good draft

Zach Cunningham ILB Two years starter for Houston. Very good pick
George Kittle TE Ehi, this guy have only 0.100$ salary??? And breaks NFL season record for receiving yards by tight end??? What a pick!!!
Marlon Mack RB Another very good pick. After rookie season from backup RB, this year run for 195 att, 908 yards and 4.7 avg
Cordrea Tankersley CB Former Clemson it was a disappointment for coach Montalbano
Jamaal Williams RB Two years without injured. Good backup RB with 121 att
Derek Rivers DE After redshirt rookie season play only 6 games with 2 tackles and 1 sack. Sure 3 rating for Action PC

BARCELONA C Another draft without great stars for Dragons, but guys i’m sure coach Tosco have other great season next year

Derek Barnett DE After encouraging rookie season with 15 games and 5 sacks, former Tennessee for problem shoulder play only 6 games with 16 tackles and 2 sacks
Blair Brown LB 17 tackles in two years. Need other…
Dan Feeney G Lost only one game in two years (25 starter), so sure can help coach Tosco. But 2018 PFF grades is only 45.5!!!
Adam Shaheen TE No more blocking TE
Dede Westbrook WR After problem with injury in the first season, former Oklahoma play all 16 games with 66 rec, 10.9 avg, 5 TD
Chris Wormley DL See above (7 games first season, 16 this). Can’t have more 4 rating from Action PC

BAYLOR B- Brown is very good pick. Same for Kupp (shame about the injury). Probably coach Banko expected much more from Reddick and Wilson

Jayon Brown ILB Play all 32 games, and this is already good, but this year improve all statistics: 97 tackles, 6 sacks (crazy number for ILB), 6 Pdef, 1 INT, 1 TD, 2 FF. Wow!!!
Josh Jones S No great numbers, and this years lost 3 games. Can’t have more 5 rating from Action PC
Tanoh Kpassagnon DE Maybe with new DC Spagnuolo and 4-3 scheme can improve. For now in two years have only 17 tackles and 2 sacks
Cooper Kupp WR Tore his ACL in November after catching 40 passes for 566 yards and six TD in 8 games. Can have limited athletically already before this injury, but guys, that hands…
Haason Reddick ILB After combine last year more analyst and GM they are crazy for him. But in the field numbers is good but no great. This year 80 tackles, 4 sacks, 1 FF, 5 Pdef
Quincy Wilson CB Again only 22 age can improve more and more. Need health (lost 12 games) and more snaps

BENSALEM A- Garrett and King can have 8-9 rating for new Action game. Also Moreau can help. Shame for Foster…

Myles Garrett DE After good but no great rookie season, this year has proved to deserve the first overall pick with this numbers: 44 tackles, 13.5 sacks, 3 FF
Reuben Foster ILB Probably he likes more to beat the women than the game. Again on the commissioner’s exempt list
Jehu Chesson WR Three receptions in two years…
Desmond King CB I love this player!!! In the new NFL nichel CB they are decisive and he is the best. Can have 8-9 rating from Action PC, and his salary is only 0.200$...
Fabian Moreau CB After zero games starter in rookie season, this year play 10 games starter with 58 tackles, 5 Pdef, 1 INT and 3 FF!!!
Donnel Pumphrey RB The NCAA’s all-time leading rusher now is only NFL practice squad…
DeMarcus Walker OLB In two years for Denver 11 tackles and two sacks…

BLACK HILLS A+ You can have A+ without finding franchise QB? Yes if draft six and maybe more players with great impact for your team. Congratulations!!!

Mike Williams WR After only 11 receptions in first year (for injury problem) has moved to 43 rec, 15.4 avg, 10 TD!!! Very good number for 2WR
Joe Mixon RB Another great improvement. Lost two games but have 237 att, 4.9 avg, 8 TD, 43 rec
Budda Baker DB More than 100 tackles (102) even lost two games. No have again INT after two seasons, but like him
Marlon Humphrey CB Defender from Alabama, so… Same Baker and Mixon lost two games this year but for me can have 8 rating from Action PC
Ryan Anderson OLB Backup for two seasons, maybe if Washington no resign Preston Smith can be starter
Shaquill Griffin CB Play 31 games (27 starter) and sure best CB Seattle for now
Taylor Moton T Last year 0 starter, this year 16… And play very well. Probably 7-8 rating from Action PC
Jonnu Smith TE After injury HB Walker i thought it could explode, but have only 20 rec and lost 3 games. Good news? 12.9 avg
Jaleel Johnson DT Same Anderson, backup for two seasons, but i see potential to be starter

BRONX B+ Watt is crazy pick, Jones can help if your QB is Brees but Lamp for now is great bust for coach Montalbano

Forrest Lamp G Need redshirt rookie season and this year play only two games (backup). Maybe next year? For now sure bust
Zay Jones WR All know Buffalo no pass more. But after first season with 27 rec improve until 56 rec. Bronx have already WR Thomas and WR Cooks, so is perfect 3WR
TJ Watt OLB Watt DNA has not betrayed. JJ brother is fantastic and after rookie season with 7 sacks improve with 13!!!
Ethan Pocic G First year with 11 starter, second with only 4… And Seattle improve OL. Maybe for this???
Rasul Douglas CB Thanks to the many injuries in the secondary Philadelphia, play all 16 games (7 starter). Only 4 Pdef but have 3 INT
Chad Williams WR Only 16 games in two seasons, and again only 20 receptions. Can’t help more coach Montalbano
Elijah McGuire RB Return from IR after week 8 this year. In two seasons have only 3.3 avg but good backup RB
Chad Hansen WR Two years, three team (NY Jets, New England, Denver) and only 9 rec…
Davis Webb QB Can’t be QB NFL

CLEVELAND B+ Rocks improve offense with pick Davis and Engram. Awuzie is good CB 6 rating

Corey Davis WR After rookie season with injury problem, he proved to be the go-to guy for Tennessee
Evan Engram HB Crazy numbers Barkley and injury (lost five games) took off target for him, but in two seasons have 109 rec, 1299 yards, 9 TD, 11.9 avg. Very very good number for HB
Chidobe Awuzie CB First season with 10 games, 25 tackles, 1 INT, this year 15 games, 71 tackles, 1 INT. Good improvement for former Colorado
Taywan Taylor WR Better to play all games with only 16 rec (last year) or lost three games but with 37 rec? Sure second for me
Tarell Basham DE Change team (from Indianapolis to NY Jets) but no improvement. Sure 3 rating Action PC
Josh Dobbs QB Backup QB for Big Ben
Michael Roberts TE 13 receptions in two seasons. Sure no future starter TE for Detroit
Deatrich Wise DE Two years with really similar stats. Good backup DE

DES MOINES A+ This grade with only three pick? Yes if draft MVP NFL and S with 9-10 rating

Jamal Adams S Pro Bowl and second All-Pro Team. Former LSU is crazy player
Patrick Mahomes QB Simply the MVP NFL. Probably QB Des Moines for next decade
Kendell Beckwith LB After good first season (6 rating Action PC) lost all 2018

EDISON C- No see players can have more 6 rating for now and future

Jarrad Davis ILB Starter from day 1 for Detroit, good ILB with problem in pass coverage but very good pass rush (8 sacks in two years)
Alex Anzalone LB Play only four games last year. This season no have problem with injury: 59 tackles, 2 sacks, 1 INT, 3 FF
Trent Taylor WR Slot WR for San Francisco have only 9.3 avg but 69 rec in two seasons
Carlos Watkins DL Last year 4 rating Action PC, this year sure 3 with only 4 games and 3 tackles

NEWARK (EX INVERNESS) A+ Watson it's a QB that you can win a Superbowl. Also add other three players can help more.

DeShaun Watson QB Houston, please take care of your franchise QB. With better OL i think can have numbers even more impressive
Takkarist McKinley DE No play again more snaps, but is very good numbers for young DE
Dalvin Tomlinson DT Good run stopper
Marcus Williams S The Minneapolis Miracle won’t define him. Former Utah is very good player and have only 22 age. Can’t have again 8 rating from Action PC, but is sure starter for new coach KRFL Garretson
Jeremy McNichols RB Select from Tampa Bay, after San Francisco, Indianapolis and Tennessee. Guys, have more team (4) then run (2)
Jalen Reeves-Maybin LB Only special team player for Detroit

KENTUCKY C- For now Peppers is good but no great player. Samuel can’t be more than WR2. Other…

Curtis Samuel WR Lost ten games in two years. Improve rec (from 15 to 39), for future need health (for him and QB Newton)
Jabrill Peppers S Starter from day 1 (lost only three games for injury) is solid S for Cleveland and coach Riley
Caleb Brantley DT Change team (from Cleveland to Washington) not help him improve, on the contrary play only 7 games with 1 tackle, yes one tackle
Rayshawn Jenkins S Already 25 age can be only backup DB

KUTZTOWN A- If Kamara had been a third round pick (same New Orleans) and not first Renegades have A+. But i'm sure Pete will be happy anyway

Alvin Kamara RB Offensive rookie of the year have 314 att, 5.1 avg, 162 receptions and 31 TD in two years!!! These numbers are crazy
Adoree' Jackson CB Former USC play all games for Tennessee with very similar stats in two seasons. Last year 7 rating Action PC, same new game?
D'Onta Foreman RB Former Texas in two years play only 11 games. Need health for improve
Gerald Everett HB Pete like play call for TE/HB and sure Everett can help with 33 rec.
Josh Reynolds WR Another pick from LA. After injury WR Kupp Reynolds it has become 3WR for Rams
Delano Hill S Can improve from 3 rating Action PC last year to 4 this year
Jordan Morgan G Coach Katsafanas no have luck with former Kutztown

NEW YORK D No picks have two good seasons and only Kazee can have future in NFL

Samaje Perine RB After good rookie season and injury rookie Guice I thought it could be starter RB for Washington. But after sign Peterson…
Trey Hendrickson DE Only backup with no more snaps and sure 3 rating next Action PC
Damontae Kazee S Best pick in last two draft for coach Dolgins. This season exploded with 7 INT!!!
Eric Saubert TE 5 rec in two seasons…

PENN STATE B+ Brady can be happy again for this draft with Njoku and Golladay

David Njoku TE This position is historically no easy for rookie, but former Miami learning fast and improve rec from 32 to 56
Justin Evans S When on the field play well, but in two seasons lost 8 games
Kenny Golladay WR After trade Golden Tate and injury Marvin Jones it has become go-to guy for QB Stafford and Detroit
Dawuane Smoot DE Can’t have more snaps with great Jacksonville DL. Maybe next year? Not sure
Xavier Woods S Last year DB for Action PC. Probably next year is only S with same rating: 5.

ROLLING GREEN A Great defensive picks for Green Grimps and for offense Cohen is a players without many equals

Jonathan Allen DL Warning!!! Crimson Tide defender!!! Bust after one season? No guys, have only problem with injury and play only 5 games. This year (all 16 games) have 61 tackles and 8 sacks…
Sidney Jones CB Remember me CB Verrett. Can be fantastic, but is always injured… Play only 10 games in two years.
Larry Ogunjobi DT Former North Carolina-Charlotte (ehi guys, someone know this college?) after first season with 5 rating Action PC improve sure. This year play all 16 games starter with 52 tackles, 5.5 sacks and 1 FF
John Johnson S After good first season this year play even better. With 119 tackles, 4 INT, 11 Pdef and 1 FF is sure 7 rating Action PC, maybe 8
Tarik Cohen RB Bears most electric offensive playmaker is also All-Pro first team a returner. Crazy pick at only 0.100$ salary

SW FLORIDA B- Great start with White but after…

Tre'Davious White CB Great pick. White can to shadowing top receivers with very good results
Gareon Conley CB Play only two games in rookie season. This year lost only one game and has been Oakland’s top cover corner
Obi Melifonwu S Played just five games as a rookie due to knee and hip injuries. This year have even less luck and play only two games
Ahkello Witherspoon CB Lost six games in two season, so can have problem with durability, but play 21 games starter for San Francisco
Montravius Adams DL For now have only rotational job for Green Bay
Josh Harvey-Clemons S College five-start recruit is only backup player in NFL
Chad Kelly QB Who???

SALEM ND Steers no have pick but is Champions!!!

SEATTLE B+ Lattimore and Jackson (at only 0.200$) is very great pick, but maybe with Mariota QB could be useful good offensive players

Marshon Lattimore CB Can’t have again 9 rating from Action PC, but defensive rookie of the year is fantastic player for coach Minshull
Kevin King CB Maybe is too thin for life in NFL. In two years lost 17 games…
Carl Lawson DE After 8 sacks in rookie season suffered a torn ACL after week 8 (before no play well with only 6 tackles and 1 sack)
Eddie Jackson S More more more probably 10 rating for next Action game. Another example of the greatness of the defenders exited from Alabama
Isaac Asiata G Play only two games in two years and have already 26 age…
Josh Malone WR Two seasons, only 7 rec. And this year Cincinnati lost early WR Green…
Malik McDowell DT Will he ever play in the NFL? Probably not, great bust for Seattle

TAMPA BAY A++ Franchise QB, crazy WR, very good RB, WR2, blind side man… Need other? Maybe impact defense but guys, what a draft for Bandits!!!

Mitchell Trubisky QB Can have problem with durability (lost 4 games last year and two this) but guys, is franchise QB. With already QB Goff in roster, coach Blume can work a very good trade for improve rest of the roster
Cam Robinson T Good rookie season in blind side protetcion for Jacksonville, suffered a torn ACL after week two. Good news? Is he shoud be 100 percent well before next season
JuJu Smith-Schuster WR Pittsburgh can trade AB without more problem? Yes, thanks to this crazy player. JuJu is already one of the league’s best wideouts
Jordan Willis DE Play all 32 games with very similar stats last year and this. Backup DE
James Conner RB Another great pick from Pittsburgh Steelers. Without Bell former Pittsburgh has become one of the best RBs of the season.
Chris Godwin WR Former Penn State play all 32 games for Tampa Bay and this year have very good numbers (59 rec, 14.3 avg, 7 TD). I think with new coach Arians can still improve a lot
Wayne Gallman RB Barkley he killed him. Last year have 111 att, 4.3 avg and 34 rec, this season 51 att, 3.5 avg and 14 rec
Will Holden T Backup OL for Arizona, play only 11 games in two years
Nazair Jones DT Last year 4 rating Action PC, next game sure 3

TENNESSEE C- Can’t see more help from this draft

Solomon Thomas DE From third overall pick we would expect more than only 4 sacks in two seasons
John Ross WR After set the record for fastest 40 time Combine at an incredible 4.22 (broke 4.24 RB Chris Johnson) it was reasonable to expect good number from former Washington. But for now have only 21 rec, only 10.0 avg and play only 16 games
Charles Harris DE Same Thomas. From first round pick 3 sacks in two year is patetic numbers
Marcus Maye S Good rookie season with 16 games (all starter). This season for problem shoulder play only 6 games
Eddie Vanderdoes DL Rookie year useful as backup DL, this season in IR
David Sharpe G Only backup OL

VANCOUVER B- With Ramczyk Commodores select one of best T in NFL. Hooker nees only health.

Malik Hooker S 5 INT in two years (no bad) but lost already 11 games
Ryan Ramczyk T Best run blocker for PFF 2018 play 31 games starter. Crazy T for coach Jenkinson at only 0.500$ salary
Teez Tabor CB His disastrous numbers at the combine they were also reflected in the field. Simply can’t have athleticism to be a starter in NFL
Tim Williams OLB Play only 15 games (0 starter) in two years. Sure 3 rating next Action game
TJ Logan RB Can’t help more with only 2 run in two season
Ryan Switzer WR Last year only 6 rec but very very good returner. This year add also 36 rec. Good pick

WARRINGTON B Maybe if Rick can select players who can play 16 games ... With more lucky this grade is easy A

Leonard Fournette RB Already a LSU he had shown problems of durability. In two seasons already lost 11 games and avg 3.7 is not crazy
OJ Howard TE Two years with crazy same avg for TE (16.6!!!). if only he could play a whole season…
Dalvin Cook RB Similar Fournette, but with durability even lower (lost 17 games!!!). Good news for next Action PC: 4.6 avg and 40 rec
Garett Boles T Have already 26 age but play always as a starter. Good blind side for Denver
Tyus Bowser OLB Two years with same tackles (11). Maybe if Baltimore no resign Suggs and Smith…
Dion Dawkins T Another no great but good tackle for coach Bieber
Pat Elflein C Last year play 14 games and have 7 rating Action, this season play again 14 games but probably have “only” 6 rating
Jourdan Lewis CB After good rookie season (54 tackles, 10 Pdef, 1 INT, 6 rating Action) play again 15 games but with a drastic decrease in statistics (12 tackles, 1 Pdef, 1 INT, more probably 4 rating Action)
Jake Butt TE Can’t have health. 3 games in two seasons…
Mack Hollins WR Lost all 2018 season. Rookie season with 16 games and 16 rec

WEST SEATTLE B+ McCaffrey is special, also Hunt before video…

Christian McCaffrey RB A white running back can be one of the best of the nfl? Yes guys. A white running back can be broke the NFL record for most catches made by a RB in a single season (107 rec!!!) Again, yes guys
Kareem Hunt RB Until week 11 2018 another crazy pick for coach Antonelli. After video of Hunt shoving and kicking a woman… No comment
Antonio Garcia T Only New England can waste third round pick (play 0 game in two year) and win, win, win…
Roderick Johnson T See above, but play 1 game in two years…
Back to top
Tue Mar 12 2019, 09:28a.m.

Registered Member #81
Joined: Mon Oct 14 2013, 08:54a.m.

Posts: 932
WOW, an A++ for me. It makes up for the "C" I got for the 2018 draft.

Thank you for doing this Valentino!!!
Back to top

Jump:     Back to top

Syndicate this thread: rss 0.92 Syndicate this thread: rss 2.0 Syndicate this thread: RDF
Powered by e107 Forum System