KRFL - a football simulation league
KRFL :: Forums :: KRFL Forums :: General League Discussions
2018 DRAFT - GRADE AFTER SEASON << Previous thread | Next thread >>
Moderators: noodles, MarkB
Author Post
Mon Feb 25 2019, 08:34a.m.
Registered Member #68
Joined: Wed Sep 14 2011, 01:54p.m.

Posts: 129
Hi guys

Just for fun... Sorry for my english, sure can find more error.

ALABAMA C+ No stars but five useful players who will be able to improve a lot already from next year

Isaiah Oliver CB Play 14 games (only two starter), have little problem in coverage but mostrly on last two game play well and Atlanta no keep CB Poole, so probably next year can be a starter
Josey Jewell LB Play all 16 games (9 starter) is very good run stop but can improve pass coverage. Denver no keep LB Marshall, so next year is sure starter and can improve again.
Ito Smith RB 14 games, 90 att, only 3.5 avg but 4 TD and more good 27 rec. Without RB Coleman next year can be perfect complement RB Devonta Freeman
Nick Nelson CB Play 10 games (only 3 starter). All know Oakland is rebuilding team, so young CB next year can be a starter.
Will Dissly TE After fantastic start season (4 games, 8 rec, 19.5 avg!!! and 2 TD) it was put in IR. Next year can be again good option for QB Russell Wilson

ATLANTA B- Two fantastic players that will be Pro Bowler before that later and RB can help more. Last two pick no play snap again in NFL but is very good draft

DJ Moore WR 55 rec, 788 yards, 14.3 avg, 2 TD. Future go to guy for QB Cam Newton, but need work for eliminated problem with fumble
Royce Freeman RB Lost battle with Lindsay for starter RB Denver, but with 130 att, 4.0 avg and 5 TD can help coach Valentino Montalbano
Fred Warner ILB Starter from week 1, play well for all season. No have sack and interception, but is very good in pass coverage and can improve in one of best ILB in NFL
Ogbonnia Okoronkwo LB No play game this year
Cedrick Wilson WR No play game this year

BARCELONA C- Vea play well in the last month, but from first pick team we could have expected more, Baker is probably best pick draft, but can't have more 6 rating on Action PC next year. With 8 picks It could have been done better

Vita Vea DT Already 24 age, Vea can be fantastic DT but lost 3 game and until the last month he has not proved he deserves to be first round pick
Austin Corbett OL It had to be the new Thomas but he could not even become a starter
Breeland Speaks LB With explosion Dee Ford and Houston can’t have more time on field. But play all 16 games (4 starter) and next year probably Houston change team
Jerome Baker ILB Miami defense have more problem last year, but Baker play all game (11 starter) with 79 tackles, 3 sacks, 1 INT and 1 TD defense. With new coach defense prone (Forbes) probably can improve again.
Arden Key DE Play all 16 games (10 starter) with 30 tackles and only 1 sack. Good news: he had no problems off the field, so the worries that made him fall into the draft could be overcome
Chukwuma Okorafor T Good backup player for Pittsburgh. Play 13 games (3 starter) and in next year can be starter for Steelers
Rick Leonard T No play game this year
Alex McGough QB No play game this year

BAYLOR A- Wow, 14 pick!!! And now Jerry have one of best RB on NFL (Barkley, of course) and franchise QB (but Darnold can decrease turnover???). Like also pick Hernandez, Goedert and Carlson while from Davenport could have expected more

Saquon Barkley RB Offensive rookie of the year and Pro Bowler. For many analist NY Giants he had to select franchise QB but is impossible no love production Barkley
Sam Darnold QB Lost 3 games and have 17 turnover (15 INT, 2 Fumble lost), but is the youngest QB in history to start a game and in some games it was wonderful. I think with new coach Adam Gase can improve more
Marcus Davenport DE After trade first round pick 2019 (trade first round not for QB???) i think New Orleans and coach Banko dream more only 4.5 sacks. Also lost 3 games and never starter. Play for University of Texas-San Antonio not same play on NFL. But Davenport is freak, so can improve
Will Hernandez G 2018 All-Rookie team, very solid OL for next decade
Dallas Goedert TE Ertz set new record for reception TE, so can’t have more target, but have great hands and 33 reception with 10.1 avg is very good result for rookie TE
DJ Chark WR Jacksonville have patetic QB, so is impossible have great number. But only 14 reception (12.4 avg) with 5 games lost really can’t help next year coach Banko
Duke Dawson CB On IR for all year. Can be good nichel CB, but need health
Tre’Quan Smith WR Play crazy game vs Philadelphia on week 11(10 receptions, 157 yards, TD). Before and after no have more target, but with 15.3 avg for season is good 3-4 WR
Rashaan Gaulden DB Can be future starter for Carolina, but for next Action PC can’t have more 3-4 ratings
Kalen Ballage RB After injury RB Frank Gore have good number carry and with 5.3 avg is solid backup for Barkley
Nathan Shepherd DL Only 15 tackles and zero sack, but play all game and with new DC Williams can improve more
Justin Jones DL Stats very similar Shepherd (17 tackles, 0.5 sack) but can help with rotation DL
Daniel Carlson K Open season with Minnesota and remember me Aguero (1-4, 25%), after release and sign for Oakland it's back to being the fantastic kicker everyone had seen in Auburn (16-17, 94.1%)
Shaquem Griffin OLB The most beautiful story in the history of the NFL and an example for everyone. But can play only with special team unit

BENSALEM B No have lucky with injury OL Wynn, but really like DB Fitpatrick and Hurst-Hand is beautiful tandem DL

Minkah Fitpatrick DB Can be DB for next Action PC, so its value increases for me. Play all 16 games with 80 tackles, 2 INT and 1 TD.
Maurice Hurst DT Lost 3 games, but he showed that the heart problems that made him lose positions in the draft did not affect his talent
Ronnie Harrison S Only 21 age is more probably next year is starter for Jacksonville
Da’Shawn Hand EL After Harrison, other Alabame defense, and Crimson Tide they almost never disappoint
Equanimeous St.Brown WR 21 rec, 15.6 avg. Play 12 games, can be good 3-4 WR
Marcus Allen S Play only 2 games for 2 tackles. Sure 3 rating on Action PC

BLACK HILLS C+ Vander Esch is fantastic, but can’t have more help from other players

Leighton Vander Esch LB Second All-Pro Team, 140 tackles and 2 INT. Dallas find new Sean Lee and coach Culler can be happy
Mason Rudolph QB Lost battle with Dobbs to be the backup of Big Ben
Mason Cole C Play all 16 games and all from starter, but 2018 PFF Grades (50.9) is horrible
Will Richardson T Jacksonville no have great OL, but him never play game
Jaylen Samuels RB After injury James Conner play starter and very well. Good 2-3 RB with very good hands
Isaac Yiadom CB Is possible next year Denver no keep CB Roby, so can be possible starter
Durham Smyth TE Play 15 games for Miami but with only 6 rec, 8.3 avg
Will Clapp OL 3 games (only 1 starter) but can play C and G, so a useful backup for OL

BRONX A Leonard is steal of the draft, McGlinchey very good T, Gallup can be great 2WR and Phillips probably is starter for next decade on Buffalo. With other RB instead of Jones (Kerryon Johnson or Nick Chubb for example) this draft have A+

Mike McGlinchey T Without discussion best T on draft 2018. Of course, All-Rookie Team. Dominant with his run-blocking
Ronald Jones RB Probably the only regret of coach Nino Montalbano. Tampa Bay with Barber no have great starter, but Jones he was never able to overcome it in the depth chart. 23 att for 1.9 avg is patetic number
Darius Leonard LB Defensive rookie of the year, first All-Pro Team, 163 tackles (best on NFL), 7 sacks, 2 INT, 4 FF. Need other?
Michael Gallup WR For team have already WR Michael Thomas and Brandin Cooks, Gallup is perfect number 3WR, can improve 2WR in future
Harrison Phillips DT With Williams retired can be solid starter
Armani Watts S Only 5 games for 5 tackles. Sure 3 ratings from Action PC
Trey Quinn WR Another players with durability problem (play only 3 games) but with Jamison Crowder FA can be next slot WR for Washington

CLEVELAND F Probably should re-evaluate this vote in a few years, but for now it is impossible to see it as a good draft. If your best pick is CB Davis, Houst… sorry Clevalnd, have a problem

Carlton Davis CB All seen defense Tampa Bay this year, correct? Also Davis lost 3 games and no have INT, with 2018 PFF grades 61.2 (87th on NFL)
Deon Cain WR Injury before open season took away from coach Hackworth WR that could play well with QB Luck and Indianapolis
Chad Thomas DE 4 games play without tackle…
Kentavius Street DE When San Francisco select him, know need redshirt season. Probably same for Mark
Mike White QB Number 3 QB for Dallas

DES MOINES A- Nelson has largely confirmed that he deserves the sixth choice in the draft

Quenton Nelson G Already one of the best three G on NFL. First All-Pro Team. 9-10 ratings from Action PC for more more years
Taven Bryan DT Play all 16 games (only one starter) with 20 tackles and 1 sack. Next year without Jackson and probably Dareus improve is more probably
Justin Reid S With first pick draft 2018 (3rd round) Houston find great player. 88 takcles, 3 INT, 1 TD (101 long!!!), 1 FF
Tim Settle, DT Same Bryan play all 16 games but with only 8 tackles and zero sack. Have 21 age, so is normal if improve
Tarvarius Moore DB Another guys play all 16 games. Starter on week 14 and 15 (in this two games have 14 tackles, 2 Pdef, 1 FF. Can be starter for alla game next year for San Francisco
Dalton Schultz TE Only 12 rec for 9.7 avg and zero TD. Sure no next Jason Witten for Dallas
Foley Fatukasi DT One game, zero tackle

EDISON B+ Coach Mays sure improve offense with this draft. Without injury problem this grade it could be an A

Sony Michel RB Lost 3 games and have only 7 reception, but run for 931 yards (209 att, 4.5 avg) with 6 TD and only 1 fumble. If see also number playoff, Dylan can only be happy with his choice
Christian Kirk WR Without injury after week 12 could be the rookie WR with the largest number receptions. Also have great connection with QB Rosen (ops, is again Rosen QB next year Arizona???) and is dynamic punt returner
Mike Hughes CB Play only 6 games but seems very very good CB. Number? 22 tackles, 3 Pdef, 1 INT, 1 TD, 1 FF
Kyle Lauletta QB Eli Manning play 16 games, so is sure. Lauletta he will not be next QB Franchise NY Giants
Troy Apke S Another demonstration that the numbers see in the combine do not always translate into the field. Play only two games for Washington
Chris Herndon TE Really good pick. For rookie TE 39 rec, 12.9 avg, 4 TD is fantastic number
Kenny Young ILB Play all 16 games (3 starter). If Baltimore lost ILB Mosley…

KENTUCKY B+ Next year sure defense improve with this draft. Offense no have lucky with injury RB Guice

Bradley Chubb OLB 60 tackles, 12 sacks!!!2 FF. Great number for great player. Of course, All-Rookie Team. And if Action PC give him DE/LB position…
Da'Ron Payne DT I've already written that Alabama's defenders almost never fail, true? Very good run stopper and 5 sacks
Derrius Guice RB Bad lucky. Need redshirt season
Rasheem Green DE 10 games for 9 tackles and 1 sack. Of course, need improve, but have only 21 age
Lorenzo Carter OLB No crazy but solid first season for former Georgia. 15 games, 43 tackles, 4 sacks and 4 PDef
Donte Jackson CB Despite very good number (74 tackles, 1 sacks, 1 FF, 4 INT) when targeted (73 times) he allowed 52 receptions for 675 yards with 3 TD
Martinas Rankin T Ehi guys, QB Watson suffered 62 sacks!!!
Joe Noteboom T Maybe when Whitworth retired can be starter, but for now is sure 3 ratings Action PC
Wyatt Teller G Former Virgina Tech play only 8 games but 7 times as a starter. Need improve but is good pick
Parry Nickerson CB 16 games (2 starter), very competitor. Like him, for me can be very good nichel CB
Scott Quessenberry C Backup OL for LA Chargers

KUTZTOWN C- Pete sure improve OL with Ragnow and Smith but rest of draft is no great

Rashaad Penny RB After 2027 rushing yards and 2698 all-purpose yards on last year College for San Diego State, Seattle and coach Katsafanas spend for him first round draft pick. Result is no great. Penny he never managed to worry role on depth chart of RB Carson and run for only 85 carrie
Frank Ragnow G Up and down season for him, but play starter for all games Detroit
Braden Smith T If Andrew Luck it was the QB that suffered less sacks, merit is also his. Very good pick
Kemko Turay DE Another pick from Indianapolis. Play 14 games with 4 sacks. Good backup for DL
DaeSean Hamilton WR Keenum season was not the same as the one played in Minnesota and Hamilton can’t have great number. 30 receptions can help Pete, but 8.1 avg…
Marquis Haynes OLB Already 25 age play only 4 games. Not sure can have future on NFL
AJ McIntosh DT Trade DT Harrison can help him for future. Now have only 5 tackles on 6 games

NEWARK (EX INVERNESS) E Only one pick for player can’t help more next year

Mike Gesicki TE Combine winners he struggled in his first season in the NFL. Play all 16 games but with only 22 rec, 9.2 avg and zero TD

NEW YORK F Cliff like trade his pick, so is normal no have great players. But on other draft selects WR Landry or WR Crowder, this time…

Dorance Armstrong DE 15 games with 13 tackles and 0.5 sack. Have 21 age, so can improve
Braxton Berrios WR Typical New England pick, but no play snap this year
Deadrin Senat DT Can help vs run game (30 tackles), can’t help for pass rush (zero sack)
PENN STATE B- Ridley give Brady another great weapon. No more help from other pick, but guys, Brady win game so is good draft
Calvin Ridley WR With DJ Moore best WR on draft. 64 rec, 12.8 avg, 10 TD!!! Very good number for rookiesh
MJ Stewart CB I have already written about the patetic defense Tampa Bay. Also lost 5 games and no have INT
Jordan Akins TE Wow, 26 age rookie. But play all 16 games with very good avg (13.2) Brady like again
Avonte Maddox CB Probably future CB nichel starter for Philadelphia. This season play 13 games with 35 tackles, 4 PDEF, 2 INT, 1 FF
Dorian O'Daniel ILB Kansas City have great problem with ILB position. Not sure him can be the answer

ROLLING GREEN A- Really like this draft. Without problem injury Johnson and Coutte no have problem give A+

Roquan Smith ILB Leonard and Vander Esch have more honors, but Smith is great ILB and play for best defense on NFL. 121 tackles, 5 sacks, 1 INT. Great number for rookie
Josh Jackson CB No have INT, but 10 Pdef and play all 16 games. I’m sure can improve more
Kerryon Johnson RB For first time since 28 November 2013 RB Detroit run for more 100 yards. Finally Lions find solid running back. Number season? 118 att, 5.4 avg!!!, 3 TD, 32 rec. Shame about the injury and for only 10 games play
Jessie Bates S Cincinnati have similar problem defense Tampa Bay but Bates is very good player. 111 tackles, 7 Pdef, 3 INT and 1 TD. And have only 21 age…
Keke Coutee WR Similar Johnson. Good number but problem with injury. Play only 6 games with 28 rec, 10.8 avg, 1 TD
Jalyn Holmes DE Only 5 games for 3 tackles and 1 sack. Sure 3 ratings Action PC
Cole Madison OL Probably he will never play in the NFL
Taron Johnson CB Good player for pick value $0.100. Play 11 games with 42 tackles, 1 sack, 3 Pdef, 1 INT, 1 FF

SW FLORIDA B+ For SuperBowl contender very solid draft. Next year Gordon and Chubb can be fantastic dynamic duo RB. Edmonds is sure ILB for next decade Buffalo and Callaway is very good 3WR. Also draft crazy punter

Tramaine Edmonds ILB The youngest draft player (20 age!!!) play very well for Buffalo. 121 tackles, 2 sacks, 2 INT, 2 FF
Hayden Hurst TE Former South Carolina, probably for problem in his foot, no have great season and lost target in favor of the other TE rookie Andrews. Only 13 rec, 12.5 avg, 1 TD
Nick Chubb RB After trade Hyde dominated the backfield Cleveland. Number is fantastic: 192 att, 5.2 avg!!!, 8 TD, 20 rec
Antonio Callaway WR Another great pick from Cleveland. His problem with marijuana no have affected for his first season NFL. Play all 16 games for 43 rec, 13.6 avg, 5 TD
Tracy Walker DB Backup DB play 16 games (zero starter) with 21 tackles, 1 INT, 2 PDef
Michael Dickson P First team All-Pro Team and Pro Bowl. What a pick!!!
John Kelly RB After injury Gurley can have carrie but LA sign CJ Anderson… Play only 4 games for 27 att and 2.7 avg

SALEM A- 13 picks for the champions KRFL. And first is James!!! Rest of draft no crazy but more solid. Really like Landry and Hines

Derwin James S Immediately after the draft was indicated as one STEAL from all analyst. And yes, James is fantastic steal. Pro Bowl, first All-Pro Team and sure 9-10 for next decade Action PC
Rashaan Evans ILB He never managed to get past Woodyard (not Wagner) in the depth chart. This draft has certainly offered better in the position
Harold Landry OLB Play 15 games (only 3 starter) with 44 tackles, 4.5 sacks, 1 FF. But next year without Orapko and Morgan is more probably improve. I see the potential for a double digit sack
Anthony Miller WR Despite problem with his shoulder, play 15 games with 33 rec, 12.8 avg and 7 TD. Good 3-4 WR
Orlando Brown T His numbers at the combine were dramatic, but now they are just a distant memory. Play all 16 games and after week 7 is starter
Hyheim Hines RB 63 receptions!!! Only this number makes it a fantastic pick. Sure a great coach Jeff as he will use it in the best way
BJ Hill DE Another very good pick. 16 games with 48 tackles, 5.5 sacks and 2 PDef. Not bad for player from the weight 303
Josh Sweat DE Only 1 tackle on 9 games. Maybe next year…
Darius Phillips CB Sure CB with 4 rating on next Action PC.
Jamarco Jones T No play game this year
Andrew Brown DE No play game this year
Bo Scarbrough RB No play game this year
Micah Kiser ILB Play all 16 games, but with only 4 tackles

SEATTLE A When you find a franchise QB at only $0.700 salary, draft can not give less than A

Lamar Jackson QB Yes, no pass well (only 58.2%), yes with LA on playoff it was dramatic, yes is not prototype QB, but guys Baltimore with him as QB changed his season. Now, same coaching staff Ravens, coach Minshull he will have to try and adapt his attack at similar player
James Daniels G Only 21 age can improve again more, but is already starter G Chicago. Like him
Dante Pettis WR Despite the injury of Garoppolo and his problems with knee (lost 4 games), is sure electric WR with 17.3 avg
Malik Jefferson ILB Cincinnati had the worst league linebacker department, but him play only for special team
Ian Thomas TE After injury Olsen his season has changed, in positive. Finally have 36 rec, 9.3 avg, 2 TD
J'Mon Moore WR Only 2 receptions for 15 yards
Justin Watson WR Only 1 recption for 5 yards
Dane Cruikshank S Play only for special team (12 games with 11 tackles)

TAMPA BAY C- Coach Blume can’t be enthusiastic about this draft. CB Alexander is good but can have season with 16 games? Only DE Hubbard play better than expected

Jaire Alexander CB Need good health (lost 3 games after more problem injury at college), but can be very good CB.
Connor Williams G Play not very well 13 games (10 starter)
Sam Hubbard DE Never a starter but play all 16 games with very good number: 39 tackles, 6 sacks, 1 FF
Oren Burks LB Backup linebacker with 24 tackles on 14 games
Alex Cappa G NFL is very different than Humboldt State College. Only 6 games without starter
Daurice Fountain WR No play game this year

TENNESSEE C- Ward can be special, but lost 3 games. Price and Edmunds are starter, but no have great season. After this players…

Denzel Ward CB Season similar to that of CB Lattimore last year, but i’m sure no have same 9 ratings from Action PC.
Billy Price C Starter, but lost 6 games and no play very well
Terrell Edmunds S Really not understand why Pittsburgh pick him from first round. At least he played all games with 78 tackles, 1 sack, 1 INT
PJ Hall DT Before the draft his quotation had a big rise and Oakland spend for him second round pick. But number is not great: 22 tackles, zero sack
Tyquan Lewis DE Only 8 games for 13 tackles and 2 sacks
Mark Walton RB 14 games for only 14 run and 2.4 avg. And in February was arrested…
Jaleel Scott WR No play game this year

VANCOUVER C For now. Of course, if Rosen becomes real franchise QB, vote change to A

Josh Rosen QB Can be next Goff that after a terrible first year it became a star? Arizona and especially coach Jenkinson hope this
Courtland Sutton WR After trade Thomas and injury Sanders i expected his numbers to explode. But unfortunately with QB Keenum it was not possible. But first season is good for him with 16 games, 42 rec and 16.8 avg
Mark Andrews TE Better than Hurst, selected long before him. Good feeling with QB Jackson, play all 16 games with 34 rec, 16.2 avg!!! and 3 TD
Tyrell Crosby T Play 10 games, backup players for Detroit
Anthony Averett CB 11 Games with only 5 tackles. Sure 3 ratings Action PC
Genard Avery LB Good pick with only $0.100 salary. Play all 16 games for Cleveland for 40 tackles, 4.5 sacks, 1 FF and 4 Pdef

WARRINGTON C- Allen can improve accuracy? Washington can be 2WR? Nwosu can play more snaps? Too many doubts for a better grade now

Josh Allen QB Even less accurate than Jackson on pass, but what legs!!! Yes, from QB need good pass, but with hard work and good system can improve.
James Washington WR Next year without Antonio Brown, if Pittsburgh no sign or draft other WR, can be perfect 2WR behind JuJu
Uchenna Nwosu OLB Play all 16 games (3 starter) with 27 tackles, 3.5 sacks. If can have more snaps, i think can improve again more
Derrick Ndadi DT Typical nose tackle, no will ever make you dream (zero sack), but it can be useful
Duke Ejiofor DE Play 12 games but with only 9 tackles and 1 sack
Kyzir White S Play starter for first 3 games LA Chargers before going in IR
Trevon Young ILB No have stats this year

WEST SEATTLE A From tradition coach Antonelli selects only offensive players, but guys this time first choice is Baker!!! Now Don have two youngs and very good QB (other is Dak) and can orchestrate a good trade to add talent or draft pick for future. No like more rest of draft, but again, first choice is Baker!!!

Baker Mayfiled QB After more, more, more, more, more (i wrote enough times more) Cleveland find his franchise QB
Kolton Miller T All season long starter on blinside for Oakland. He had some problems in pass protection but play well
Brian O'Neill T Play 15 games (11 starter) for Minnesota. Another young and sure future starter T for coach Antonelli
Brandon Parker T On the opposite side of Miller, play 15 games (11 starter) but with great problem in pass protection
Geron Christian OL When for the many injury of the OL Washington went into the field (only two times) it was disastrous
Brian Allen C Backup C for LA Rams
Russell Gage WR Play 15 games but with only 6 receptions and 10.5 avg
Back to top
Mon Feb 25 2019, 01:59p.m.

Registered Member #81
Joined: Mon Oct 14 2013, 08:54a.m.

Posts: 932
Thank you for doing this Valentino!
Back to top

Jump:     Back to top

Syndicate this thread: rss 0.92 Syndicate this thread: rss 2.0 Syndicate this thread: RDF
Powered by e107 Forum System